London — Years late and massively over-budget, Europe's first EPR nuclear reactors are finally about to load fuel and energize.
Receive daily email alerts, subscriber notes & personalize your experience.Register Now
This is the final act in the region's longest-running generation construction saga, with delivery of first power from EPRs in Finland and France due before end-2019.
Ten years late and 2.5 times over its original Eur3.2 billion budget, TVO's 1.6 GW Olkiluoto-3 project in Finland could produce up to 4 TWh next year ahead of full operation in early 2020 - assuming the latest delay announced in November is the last.
Meanwhile a mere eight years late and, at Eur10.5 billion, three times over budget, EDF's 1.6 GW Flamanville 3 project in Normandy, northern France is due to deliver first power in summer 2019 if it can clear regulatory concern over welds. Even when complete, there is a cloud hanging over this project because of anomalies found in its reactor pressure vessel head and bottom. Regulator ASN has said the closure head must not be used beyond 2024.
For Finland, commissioning of O-3 will go a long way to erasing the country's multi-year supply deficit, freeing up Norwegian and Swedish hydro resource. For France, operational scrutiny will be intense as EDF seeks to prove the design and build a case for further units.
These baseload additions buck the longer term trend towards growing volatility in generation, as renewables displace conventional thermal.
Additions of 9 GW next year across west Europe are skewed towards onshore and offshore wind, while closures of 12 GW are almost exclusively of coal, nuclear or gas plant, according to data from S&P Global Platts Analytics.
For the year just passed, over 15 GW of thermal generation closed across Europe, offset by just 3 GW of gas plant additions. Meanwhile 24 GW of wind and solar were added, according to Entso-e.
The year on year removal of thermal generation now means that Finland, Hungary, Northern-Central Italy, Southern-Central Italy and Lithuania rely on imports throughout winter.
Under harsh winter conditions others become reliant on imports, including Austria, Belgium, Slovakia and Slovenia.
Tighter EU carbon market set to prompt more power fuel switching in Europe
2019 is set to be the year that coal-to-gas switching in power generation takes off in continental Europe. Carbon prices supported by the new market stability reserve cutting supplies, coupled with potentially lower gas prices, could prompt unprecedented C2G switching volumes.Listen in full
This is ahead of a slew of more determined energy transition actions by European governments, phasing out big chunks of coal and nuclear plant in the early to mid-2020s.
Looking ahead, Platts Analytics sees 65 GW of net coal and nuclear closures over next seven years, nearly double the level of closures seen over the last seven years.
The coal closures are front-loaded in the period, with heavy losses across Germany, the UK and Spain before end-2020, ahead of total phase-outs in France (2022, 3 GW to go), the UK (2025, nearly 7 GW to go post-2020) and the Netherlands (2030, NB confirmation of the Urgenda ruling this year could front-load closures of around 1 GW).
Nuclear reductions start to hit home with 10 GW of German capacity closed by 2022, followed by removal of 6 GW of Belgian capacity by 2025, and the loss of 4.3 GW in the UK between 2024-2026.
Beyond this, France has rowed back on Hollande-era legislation to cut nuclear's share in the mix to 50% by 2025, with 2035 the new target date. With the closure of Fessenheim being de-linked from commissioning of Flamanville 3, the government is increasingly risk-averse given its pledge to close coal in the near term, a decision system operator RTE remains wary of.
Earlier in the political process and harder to call is Germany's coal/lignite plan. For some months sector analysts have focused on 2038 as a potential final phase out date, with production effectively needing to halve if the country is to meet 2030 climate targets.
Assuming the government's 65% RES target is achieved by 2030, Germany may then be able to get away with retaining its more modern fleet of post-2000 power stations (9 GW hard coal, 7GW lignite), if backed post-2030 by reserves similar to the current lignite reserve, under which older units are removed from the market, then closed after four years.
LAST HURRAH FOR NEW COAL
Conventional thermal plant additions across Europe are getting as rare as hen's teeth, with Poland the only truly active market.
For coal, and ignoring the anomaly of Datteln in Germany, the only remaining new plant construction is in Central and East Europe, with big coal units close to completion at Opole (2x 900 MW) and Jaworzno II (910 MW) in Poland.
The fate of the 1 GW Ostroleka C coal project, meanwhile, is about to be decided as its Polish investor group (Enea, Energa) await the outcome of the country's 2023 capacity auction, due to be held in December. Enea's CEO, Miroslaw Kowalik, characterized the Zloty 218/kW/yr clearing price in a first auction for 2021 delivery as "very promising". Ostroleka C could well be Europe's last coal-fired project to get away.
|Major capacity additions 2019 (MW)|
|* including smaller country adds|
|Source: S&P Global Platts Analytics|
|Retirements, mothballings 2019 (MW)|
|Other: Finland 150 MW (coal); Netherlands 430 MW (gas); Norway 280 MW (gas)|
|Source: S&P Global Platts Analytics|
--Henry Edwardes-Evans, email@example.com