Research — Nov 14, 2026
From Signal to Action II: Introducing Credit Ratings Level Specific Cutoffs on Credit Transitions Signals for Better Informed Decisions
By Michelle Cheong and Arun Kumar Singh
In our preceding study, From Signal to Action, we showed how static probability cutoffs on Credit Transition Signals (CTS) can serve as practical triggers for action, for example, flagging an issuer when the probability of improvement exceeds 20% or deterioration exceeds 30%.
In this paper, we advance the existing methodology by calibrating rating-specific thresholds for these signals, thereby improving the precision and relevance of CTS-based alerts. Our backtests indicate that using rating-specific cut-offs can improve the efficacy of detecting ratings transitions by 3.5 times; and get ahead of these changes by 5 to 5.6 months on average.
These tailored thresholds are utilized to configure alerts across platforms for:
- Risk managers overseeing high-yield portfolios, who need sharper differentiation among already-elevated risk signals;
- Credit analysts and risk teams tracking investment-grade-to-speculative-grade migration (e.g., for IFRS 9 staging, or portfolios with low-risk mandates);
- Quantitative strategy teams, who can test different sensitivity levels ("k") to fine-tune alpha-generation signals.
- Banks performing due diligence for Basel III/IV requirements, who can focus on entities with higher probability of deterioration.
CTS are statistical model outputs produced by S&P Global Market Intelligence. They are not predictions, guarantees or indications of future rating actions. The material contained herein is for informational purposes only, does not constitute tax advice, and should not be used as a substitute for consultation with professional accounting, tax, legal or other professional advisers. S&P Global Market Intelligence is a division independent from S&P Global Ratings.
Background: The rationale for credit Ratings-specific cutoffs
As shown in the preceding paper, a core strength of the CTS model lies in its construction: it is built on a foundation of fundamental credit analysis (credit Ratings, macroeconomic factors, and company financials), with market-based indicators (such as bond spreads and equity-implied default risk) layered on top as an adjustment model when market pricing diverges meaningfully from fundamentals. This produces a more stable and reliable signal than models that blend fundamental and market inputs with equal weighting, which tend to be noisier and more prone to short-term volatility and mean reversion.
However, a single uniform cutoff across all rating levels has a key limitation: speculative-grade Ratings (BB+ and below) show much higher realized transition rates than investment-grade Ratings (BBB- and above), with the gap widening further into high-yield and CCC/CC territory (Figure 1).
Figure 1: Historical (realized) 1-year upgrades and downgrades (%) by S&P Global Ratings levels.
Source: Research from Credit Solutions Thought Leadership. Credit Ratings history is sourced from CreditPro® from S&P Global Market Intelligence. As of October 2026. For illustration only.
In practical terms, this means that risk managers monitoring a broad portfolio may see a disproportionate volume of alerts from speculative-grade names, while early warning signs on investment-grade issuers, where transitions are rarer but could be consequential, could be missed under a one-size-fits-all threshold.
Methodology: How we set Ratings specific cutoffs
For readers less familiar with the statistical approach, this section walks through the four-step process, with results in the appendix. The methodology of finding optimal cutoffs balancing precision and recall (F1 statistics) follows from the previous article.
Step 1: Measure historical Ratings transition behavior.
We calculated the historical mean transition rate, plus a range of standard deviation bands (denoted "k," ranging from 0 to 3.0), for upgrades and downgrades at each rating level. This used daily CTS data from 2013 to 2026, using data in the research dataset for model building purposes[1]. This results in a daily CTS sample data of 466 entities (i.e. a subset of the full universe) and 73,628 daily CTS signals with a longer history across more than one credit cycle. Because transition data is inherently noisy, the raw relationship between rating level and transition frequency did not increase smoothly from AAA to CCC.
Step 2: Split the sample by the CTS model type and Creditwatch/Outlook status
We noted the statistical distribution of CTS is not continuous, but “jumps” when Outlook or Creditwatch moved from Stable to Positive or Negative. Hence, we want to see if a lower threshold could be warranted when Outlook is stable; to get an earlier warning on deterioration and improvement. Finally, we computed different cutoffs for Corporates and Financial Institutions as these stem from different CTS models.
Step 3: Smooth the relationship between rating and transition rates.
To address this noise, we applied a piecewise smoothing function that increases monotonically (consistently upward, without reversals) from AAA to C. The logic behind this function reflects how credit risk behaves across the rating scale:
- AAA to A-: Default risk is near zero, and transition rates are flat and highly stable, consistent with the very low volatility credit analysts observe in top-tier issuers.
- BBB+ to BB-: Transition rates begin a gentle upward slope, reflecting the increasing sensitivity of credit quality as issuers approach the investment-grade/speculative-grade boundary, a transition zone of particular interest to risk managers tracking rating migration risk.
- B+ to C: Transition rates rise more steeply, reflecting the higher volatility and default risk characteristic of distressed credits.
Step 4: Identify cutoffs for probability of improvement and deterioration.
We tested various standard-deviation bands above the smoothed average transition rates from Step 2, selecting cutoffs that optimize the F1 score, a statistical measure that balances precision (avoiding false alarms) against recall (not missing real transitions)[2]. Across different smoothing approaches, the optimal band ranged from +0.05 to +1.85 standard deviations relative to the historical average Probability of Deterioration / Improvement. Figure 2 and the Appendix present illustrative cutoffs from one such near-optimal calibration, intended as a practical starting point for implementation.
The optimal standard deviation bands above average ranged between 0.1 to 1.5 when different smoothing techniques were applied, depending on whether Outlook was stable, Positive or Negative. For setting alerts, we included sample cut-off values as rules of thumb in the Appendix, illustrated in Figure 2 below.
Figure 2: An illustration of Credit Ratings specific CTS cutoffs
Source: Research from Credit Solutions Thought Leadership. The underlying data is from Credit Transition Signals on RatingsDirect® on CaptialIQ Pro. Credit Ratings history is sourced from CreditPro® from S&P Global Market Intelligence. As of October 2026. For illustration only
Key performance findings:
- Issuers breaching the rating-specific cutoff experienced, on average, up to 3.5 times higher transition volume (upgrades or downgrades) over the following year compared to the historical base rate, a measure we refer to as Estimation Lift. For risk managers, this means a flagged issuer breaching the threshold is meaningfully more likely to transition than an average issuer at that rating, justifying closer monitoring or review.
- These cutoffs provided an average lead time of approximately 5-5.6 months ahead of the actual rating action, giving both risk managers and credit analysts a meaningful window to reassess exposure, hedge, or escalate internal credit review ahead of a public rating change.
Case study of Company X in North America
Between mid-2024 and October 2026, a North American company was downgraded from BBB- to BB (Figure 3). This case study illustrates how rating-specific CTS cutoffs provided earlier and clearer signals than a static, one-size-fits-all threshold would have.
Figure 3: S&P Global Ratings History for Company X from 2022 to 2026
Source: The underlying data is from Ratings & History on RatingsDirect® on CaptialIQ Pro. from S&P Global Market Intelligence. As of October 2026. For illustration only
A review of CTS data shows that the Probability of Deterioration (shown in orange) remained above our candidate BBB- rating-specific threshold of 11-13% for most of this period, even when Outlook was Stable. CTS continued to worsen as the issuer approached its eventual downgrade. (Figure 4). This tells us that the CTS signal could be used as an early warning on credit risk deterioration over and above Ratings, Outlook and CreditWatch.
To understand the behavior of the CTS signal, we split the historical data into distinct timeframes (or regimes), each reflecting a shift in CTS signal behavior (Figure 4).
Figure 4: Credit Transitions Signals History from 2016 to 2026
Source: The underlying data is from Credit Transition Signals on RatingsDirect® on CaptialIQ Pro. from S&P Global Market Intelligence. As of October 2026. For illustration only
Period 1 (P1): Prior to Mid-2017, Stable Credit Profile
CTS remained below both the improvement and deterioration cutoffs, with a probability of improvement of 9.4% and probability of deterioration of 5.5%. Supporting fundamentals included:
- Cash flow and profitability: FFO-to-Debt of 40.2% and Return on Capital of 14.9%, both indicative of healthy debt-servicing capacity.
- Low market risk premium: Distance to Default stood at three standard deviations above the default point, reflecting strong equity market confidence.
- Stable Ratings Outlook
Period 2 (P2): Late 2017 to 2020, Early Warning Signs Emerge
CTS rose above threshold levels for most of this period, coinciding with:
- A Negative Ratings Outlook in 2018 (later revised to stable in 2019).
- Weakening cash flow coverage: FFO-to-Debt declined to 23.1% in 2018, driven by debt raised to fund an acquisition.
- Declining profitability: Return on Capital fell to 9.1% in 2018, as the company absorbed an acquisition that doubled its size, a classic integration risk scenario relevant to both credit analysts (assessing balance sheet strain) and risk managers (assessing event risk).
Period 3 (P3): 2021 to 2022, Temporary Optimism
CTS showed a brief improvement as the Probability of Improvement rose, before fading as earnings disappointed:
- Growth optimism: Total assets expanded to three times their pre-merger size.
- Positive Ratings Outlook, supported by management's commitment to revenue delivery.
- Revenue growth driven by consolidation of the merged entities.
- However, market-based indicators remained volatile, reflecting ongoing uncertainty around integration and execution risk, an early signal that market participants were less convinced than the stated Outlook suggested.
Period 4: 2023 to Mid-2024, Deterioration Takes Hold
CTS began to clearly deteriorate, with the probability of deterioration rising as the probability of improvement declined:
- Profitability turned Negative: Return on Capital fell to -1.7% in 2023, also pressuring interest coverage.
- Credit Model divergence: Quantitative credit scoring models using the most recent financials pointed to further downside risk.
- Ratings Outlook turned Negative, as Debt/EBITDA breached levels required to sustain the existing rating.
Period 5 (Mid-2024 to 2025) and Period 6 (Early 2026): Sustained Deterioration
The probability of deterioration spiked sharply and remained elevated:
- Revenue contraction: A 15% decline in FY2024-2025 revenue, despite management's efforts to divest unprofitable non-core assets.
- Elevated market risk premium: Secondary bond spreads widened materially, pricing the issuer's debt consistent with a speculative-grade profile, an early market signal that preceded the formal rating action.
- Rating action: S&P Global Ratings downgraded the issuer to 'BB+' in June 2025, with a CreditWatch Negative designation.
Period 7 June 2026 to October 2026: Stabilization post Ratings downgrade
S&P Global Ratings further lowered the rating to 'BB' on October 12, 2026, but revised the Outlook to Stable. CTS's probability of deterioration normalized accordingly:
- Although underlying fundamentals had not materially improved, the model indicated that further deterioration from the BB level was unlikely.
- Mixed market signals: The Distance to Default metric recovered to 8.34, suggesting equity investors were pricing in a potential recovery. However, the Bond Implied Signal remained at speculative grade, indicating bond investors remained cautious, highlighting a useful divergence for analysts and risk managers to monitor going forward.
Conclusion
This paper extends the practical application of Credit Transition Signals by introducing rating-specific cutoffs, addressing a key limitation of static, uniform cutoffs identified in our earlier work. For risk managers, this means fewer false Positives from speculative-grade exposures and more reliable early warnings on investment-grade holdings, particularly valuable for portfolios with regulatory or mandate-driven sensitivity to rating migration. For credit analysts, the rating-specific framework offers a more calibrated lens for interpreting CTS alongside fundamental and market-based indicators, as demonstrated in the Company X case study, where the sustained breach of the BBB- threshold provided a clear, early signal of deterioration well before the formal downgrade.
The underlying methodology, combining historical transition analysis, statistical smoothing, and F1-optimized thresholding, resulted in an average 3 to 5x Estimation Lift and approximately five months of lead time ahead of actual rating actions. The Company X case further illustrates how this approach performs through multiple phases of a real credit cycle: from early-stage fundamental deterioration, through acquisition-driven stress, to eventual downgrade and stabilization, with the CTS signal tracking each phase with appropriate sensitivity.
Such Ratings specific cutoffs can be a practical enhancement to existing CTS-based monitoring frameworks for both risk managers and credit analysts, while tailoring the specific cutoffs (and the "k" sensitivity parameter) to their own risk appetite, portfolio composition, and use case.
Important Disclosure:
Credit Transition Signals are not created or maintained by, associated with, or representative of any S&P Global Ratings credit rating or Outlook. The product is produced by S&P Global Market Intelligence, a division independent from S&P Global Ratings. S&P Global Ratings makes no representation regarding the product. The product is a statistical model that considers input based on publicly available information. The product is representative of probabilities and is not a prediction; it is not informed by knowledge of upcoming rating actions and is not a guarantee or indication of a future rating action. A credit rating action, if taken, may differ regarding timing, extent of movement, and/or direction compared to the product. The product may diverge from the Outlook published by S&P Global Ratings. For questions, contact S&P Global Market Intelligence at Capital IQ Pro Client Support. For more information, see the Credit Transition Signals Whitepaper.
Content Type
Language