A U.S. District Judge in Chicago reversed a verdict against AbbVie Inc. in a lawsuit by a man who alleged that the company fraudulently misrepresented the risks of AndroGel, a testosterone replacement drug, Reuters reported.
Judge Matthew Kennelly in Chicago said the findings of the jury that held the company responsible were "logically incompatible," the news outlet reported.
A jury had previously ruled in favor of Oregon resident Jesse Mitchell, awarding him $150 million in punitive damages but nothing in compensatory damages. It concluded that AbbVie was not negligent or strictly liable for a heart attack suffered by the plaintiff after taking the drug, but said the company falsely marketed AndroGel.
"The irreconcilable conflict between the jury's finding of liability on the fraudulent misrepresentation claim and award of zero compensatory damages requires a new trial on this claim," Kennelly wrote.
Kennelly's ruling erased the punitive damages award, Reuters reported. A new trial is now scheduled for March 5.