trending Market Intelligence /marketintelligence/en/news-insights/trending/_7we-cQ7CA48wisfMLt6lQ2 content
Log in to other products

Login to Market Intelligence Platform


Looking for more?

Contact Us

Request a Demo

You're one step closer to unlocking our suite of comprehensive and robust tools.

Fill out the form so we can connect you to the right person.

If your company has a current subscription with S&P Global Market Intelligence, you can register as a new user for access to the platform(s) covered by your license at Market Intelligence platform or S&P Capital IQ.

  • First Name*
  • Last Name*
  • Business Email *
  • Phone *
  • Company Name *
  • City *
  • We generated a verification code for you

  • Enter verification Code here*

* Required

Thank you for your interest in S&P Global Market Intelligence! We noticed you've identified yourself as a student. Through existing partnerships with academic institutions around the globe, it's likely you already have access to our resources. Please contact your professors, library, or administrative staff to receive your student login.

At this time we are unable to offer free trials or product demonstrations directly to students. If you discover that our solutions are not available to you, we encourage you to advocate at your university for a best-in-class learning experience that will help you long after you've completed your degree. We apologize for any inconvenience this may cause.

In This List

DC Circuit gives US EPA more time to reconsider coal ash pond closure deadline

European Energy Insights July 2020

As COVID-19 Wears On, Regulators Examine Moratorium Extensions, Cost Recovery

Essential Energy Insights - June 11, 2020

Webinar Replay

Deep Dive on Oil & Gas for Financial Institutions

DC Circuit gives US EPA more time to reconsider coal ash pond closure deadline

A federal appeals court granted the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's request for more time to reconsider a rulemaking that extended the lives of unlined coal ash ponds, accepting utilities' assertions that vacating the extension would threaten the reliability of the nation's electric grid.

In doing so, a three-judge panel for the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit denied a request from environmental groups to stay or vacate the EPA's move to let unlined coal ash ponds continue operating until October 2020.

The legal challenge revolves around the EPA's 2015 Coal Combustion Residuals, or CCR, rule, which set the first-ever national standards for the safe handling and storage of ash and other residuals generated from burning coal for electricity.

Under that rule, wet surface impoundments known as ash ponds were required to demonstrate compliance by Oct. 17, 2018. Among its many provisions, the CCR rule specifically prohibited certain levels of toxic coal ash constituents in groundwater and required ash ponds to be located at least five feet from the uppermost aquifer. Ponds that violated those provisions were required to initiate closure within six months — or as early as April 2019.

In July 2018, however, the Trump administration extended the closure deadline to October 31, 2020, to give utilities more time to develop alternative coal ash disposal capacity.

The issue gained complexity in August 2018 when the D.C. Circuit, citing public health and environmental concerns, struck down a provision of the Obama-era CCR rule that allowed unlined ponds to continue operating unless a leak was detected. The ruling effectively required all unlined ash ponds to close, but the court did not set a deadline for those closures.

Environmental groups, led by the Waterkeeper Alliance, challenged the EPA's deadline extension the following October, arguing that the move was inconsistent with the D.C. Circuit's opinion that all unlined ash ponds should cease operating. The groups also alleged that the extension was unlawful because it was issued without prior notice and without giving the public an opportunity to comment.

Meanwhile, the EPA asked the court to remand its July 2018 rulemaking for further consideration and allow it to finalize further revisions consistent with the D.C. Circuit's August 2018 decision.

In December 2018, environmental petitioners moved to stay or partially vacate the deadline extension, arguing that their members would be "irreparably harmed" by allowing unlined ash ponds to continue receiving coal residuals. In response, the Utilities Solid Waste Activities Group, a trade organization that represents companies with significant amounts of coal-fired generation, argued in a Jan. 22 filing that doing so "would cause regulatory uncertainty and significant disruption to the nation's power supply."

The EPA echoed the group's warning in its own Jan. 29 filing, arguing that unlined coal ash ponds would be required to initiate closure immediately if the July 2018 rulemaking were set aside. Environmental groups, meanwhile, contended that the EPA's own submissions to the court indicate that alternative disposal arrangements are readily available.

The D.C. Circuit on March 13 sided with the EPA after considering both arguments, finding that the agency and industry intervenors demonstrated that "the consequences of vacatur would be disruptive." In its motion for remand, the EPA estimated that it could conclude a notice-and-comment rulemaking to revise its July 2018 changes to the CCR rule "no sooner than nine months from the date that remand is granted."

The D.C. Circuit case is Waterkeeper Alliance et al. v. EPA et al. (No. 18-1289).