13 Apr, 2022

US renewable sector gears up for battle over final China competition bill

SNL Image

Lawmakers in Congress are preparing to reconcile technology competitiveness legislation after both the U.S. House of Representatives and Senate passed their own respective bills on the issue.
Source: Geoff Livingston/Moment via Getty Images

A massive technology manufacturing and innovation bill is set to undergo a bicameral conference process in Congress. U.S. clean energy backers hope to see proposed funding and trade provisions for the industry included in the legislation.

However, negotiations over the bill — aimed at helping the U.S. better compete against China — are expected to be difficult, with the House and Senate versions of the bill differing in key areas and certain segments of the solar power industry at odds over the trade language.

In late March, the Senate passed its version of the legislation, originally known as the United States Innovation and Competition Act, or USICA. The move came after the House passed its own competitiveness bill, named the America COMPETES Act. House and Senate lawmakers are now set to participate in a conference to reconcile the two packages.

Trade tensions

One of the biggest complications for the energy industry is related to trade provisions. Domestic solar component manufacturers support language in the House bill designed to crack down on imports from countries or companies seeking to avoid antidumping and countervailing duties. Supporters say the provisions will help curb attempts by China to circumvent those duties by transshipping solar power components through other countries or partly manufacturing in other countries before sending the products to the U.S.

The anticircumvention proposal was not included in the Senate bill. U.S. solar installers fear the provisions could substantially raise costs for new projects.

Solar developers say the proposal could open the door to more circumvention investigations similar to the one requested by California-based solar manufacturer Auxin Solar Inc. In the company's petition, which the U.S. Commerce Department granted in late March, Auxin accused Chinese producers of crystalline silicon solar cells and modules of assembling products in Malaysia, Thailand, Vietnam and Cambodia from parts and components made in China to avoid paying antidumping and countervailing duties.

Although the Senate passed USICA on a bipartisan basis, the House legislation received almost no votes from Republicans, putting the fate of the anticircumvention provisions in a compromise bill in question. The final bill will need 60 votes to avoid a Senate filibuster. That would require at least some Republicans to back the anticircumvention provisions in the evenly divided Senate.

In another key difference between the two bills, USICA proposed to reinstate all exclusions for Section 301 tariffs that the U.S. put in place against China in 2017 — language that was not included in the House legislation. USICA would also require refunds on tariffs paid for goods imported after 2020 whose exclusions lapsed. The Trump administration had authorized exclusions for thousands of products in relation to a Section 301 investigation against China, but most of the exclusions expired at the end of 2020.

The American Council on Renewable Energy said it backs the Section 301 exclusions, which can allow U.S. renewable energy developers to avoid tariffs for crucial imported materials if they do not violate fair trade standards. The provisions could have a "huge impact" on the industry, ACORE's Vice President of Policy Allison Nyholm said in an interview.

"We've received specific feedback from our industry, whether it's storage or offshore wind," Nyholm said. "The potential for taking advantage of that cuts across the industry."

Other energy provisions

The House bill also contained several provisions to support clean energy that were not contained in the Senate bill.

The America COMPETES Act would provide $3 billion for domestic solar energy manufacturing and $375 million to create a strategic transformer reserve. Amendments were also adopted to ease renewable energy development in federal areas and to end a moratorium on federal offshore wind lease sales in the eastern Gulf of Mexico and off the coasts of North Carolina, South Carolina, Georgia and Florida.

With a final bill needing at least some bipartisan support in the Senate, Democrats would have to get Republicans in the upper chamber on board with the clean energy proposals if they are to survive. Some of the House clean energy measures were originally stand-alone bills that had bipartisan support, but Senate lawmakers may not agree to include them as part of this bigger bill.

"I think it's going to be complicated," Tanya Das, associate director of the Bipartisan Policy Center's energy program, said in an interview. "The energy provisions in [the two bills] are, for the most part, very, very different."

Adding further complications, over 100 lawmakers will be participating in the conference process, meaning many voices and priorities will be competing for attention, Das said.

But Das highlighted areas of potential agreement. Both the House and Senate bills contain measures to bolster clean energy research, including a proposal that would require the U.S. Department of Energy to form a nonprofit foundation to mobilize private sector financing for energy technologies.

"I think folks really recognize the importance of the energy sector in our nation's competitiveness, so we are optimistic that we'll get to see some really robust support for these programs included," Das said. "It's just a question of what exactly they'll be willing to land on."

S&P Global Commodity Insights produces content for distribution on S&P Capital IQ Pro.