State of the Pipeline – October 2025

This feature has the latest news from the mutual bank conversion sector. As of Oct. 29, three conversions were in the pipeline.

The newly issued shares of Baldwinsville, New York-based Seneca Bancorp Inc. began trading Oct. 16, closing up 2.2% from the $10 offering price. The company's second-stage conversion priced slightly below the midpoint of the offering range.

Seneca is expanding its branch network. It opened a branch in Manlius, New York, on June 2. The company disclosed in a prospectus that it expects to establish a branch in late 2026 in Camillus, New York; Seneca agreed to purchase 1.2 acres of land there on June 25.

Seneca also plans to open a branch in Clay, New York, where, in 2024, it bought 2.5 acres of land directly across from the future site of a semiconductor fabrication facility to be established by Micron Technology Inc. Seneca's property could be developed in late 2027 or 2028. "This strategic investment positions us to support the economic growth expected in the region and to provide financial solutions to businesses and families as this transformative development takes shape," Seneca said in the filing.

Oak Park, Illinois-based Hoyne Bancorp Inc. has issued a prospectus in conjunction with its mutual-to-stock conversion. The offering expires Nov. 5. The price to pro forma tangible book value as of June 30 is between 39.7% at the minimum of the offering range and 51.9% at the supermax. If the deal prices at the bottom end of the range, it would represent the second-lowest valuation among all US mutual bank conversions of the century.

On Sept. 23, PSB Financial Inc. filed a registration statement for a mutual-to-stock conversion. PSB is the proposed holding company for Pioneer State Bank, the successor to Deer Lodge, Montana-based Pioneer Federal Savings and Loan Association. The price to pro forma tangible book value as of June 30 is between 40.1% at the minimum of the offering range and 52.2% at the supermax.

In the filing, PSB said, "We are considering branching opportunities that may arise in our primary market area, including a potential branch office in western Montana in late 2026 or the first six months of 2027."

On Sept. 12, URSB Bancorp Inc., the proposed holding company for Carteret, New Jersey-based United Roosevelt Savings Bank, filed a registration statement for a mutual-to-stock conversion. Gross proceeds are between $14.9 million at the minimum of the offering range and $23.1 million at the supermax.

According to the filing, many of United Roosevelt's one- to four-family, multifamily, commercial and industrial (C&I), and consumer loans have been purchased rather than originated internally. As of June 30, the balance of purchased C&I loans from BHG Financial, formerly known as Bankers Healthcare Group LLC, was $35.9 million, or 13.7% of the bank's loan portfolio. United Roosevelt began buying C&I loans from BHG in early 2016. The bank also started buying participation interests in syndicated leveraged lending loans in November 2023 from BancAlliance Inc.; the balance of that exposure on June 30 was $3.3 million. Additionally, United Roosevelt began purchasing consumer loans from BHG and Woodside Credit LLC in the second quarter and from LendingClub Corp. in the first quarter.

Download a template showing the conversion pipeline, market performance of recent conversions, valuations of mutual holding companies and a list of conversion candidates.