trending Market Intelligence /marketintelligence/en/news-insights/trending/4lNpjUnPg5W3d55mwpwebQ2 content esgSubNav
In This List

SEC says Dodd-Frank had little effect on capital, market liquidity


Gauging the Impact of Rate Changes, Growth, and Foreign Fluctuations on the US Economy


2023 Big Picture: US Consumer Survey Results


Insight Weekly: Bank mergers of equals return; energy tops S&P 500; green bond sales to rise


Insight Weekly: US companies boost liquidity; auto insurers hike rates; office sector risk rises

SEC says Dodd-Frank had little effect on capital, market liquidity

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission released a report Aug. 8 claiming that Dodd-Frank regulations, including the much-debated Volcker rule, did not damage capital and market liquidity. The report added that conditions in some cases actually improved since post-crisis regulatory reforms.

Congress commissioned the 315-page report as part of a specific review of the Dodd-Frank financial regulatory framework, in addition to other regulations such as Basel III, which Congress designed the report to guide considerations for the appropriations process, which authorizes government spending.

On capital formation, the SEC noted that about $20.20 trillion in capital was formed from the signing of Dodd-Frank in 2010 until 2016. The SEC found that capital formation was not lower after financial regulatory reform, and that primary market security issuance may have been higher around the implementation of the JOBS Act, a 2012 bill that loosened some restrictions on capital access for small businesses. More specifically, the SEC saw an increase in the number of small company initial public offerings.

In the private market, the report said debt and equity issuance increased "substantially" from $1.16 trillion in 2009 to $1.87 trillion in 2015.

The SEC also addressed concerns about market liquidity, which Republicans have highlighted following a Federal Reserve paper exploring the possible damage of the Volcker rule, which restricts proprietary trading, to corporate bond markets.

The report says that trading activity and average transaction costs have generally "improved or remained flat," with transaction costs actually decreasing for smaller trade sizes relative to the precrisis period. The SEC notes, however, that dealers in corporate bond markets have broadly reduced their capital commitment since 2007, although there has not been a "commensurate decrease" in the number of dealers participating in the market.

In the U.S. Treasury market, the SEC found "no support" for a link between the Volcker rule and market liquidity conditions, since U.S. cash Treasurys are exempt from the rule.

"Overall, it is not clear that corporate bond market liquidity has deteriorated following the enactment of the Dodd-Frank Act," the report reads.

The SEC's Division of Economic and Risk Analysis, which wrote the report, cautioned that it is difficult to evaluate the causal relationship of Dodd-Frank to capital and market liquidity, due to factors like macroeconomic conditions and market participant behavior. Unlike the U.S. Treasury report released in June, the SEC report does not include specific policy recommendations.