IN THIS LIST

Unequal Opportunities: SPIVA Europe U.K. Active Fund Performance in H1 2026

Up, but Not Across

One Toolkit, Many Markets: The Global Evolution of Options-Based ETFs

The Changing Calculus of Diversification

Droning On About Defense: A Reimagined Vision for Europe

Unequal Opportunities: SPIVA Europe U.K. Active Fund Performance in H1 2026

Contributor Image
Euan Smith

Quantitative Analyst, Index Investment Strategy

S&P Dow Jones Indices

Unequal Opportunities: SPIVA Europe U.K. Active Fund Performance in H1 2026

The first half of 2026 was an eventful one for markets. The AI buildout, war in the Middle East and rising government bond yields competed for attention globally. In the U.K., domestic political uncertainty added to the mix. This backdrop created opportunities for U.K. active funds, but their ability to make the most of them varied by category.

Equity market dispersion, which is the spread of constituent returns, provides one measure of market opportunity. Exhibit 1 shows that dispersion increased across the U.K. equity market in H1 2026, creating greater scope to add value.1

Unequal Opportunities: SPIVA Europe U.K. Active Fund Performance in H1 2026: Exhibit 1

Source: S&P Dow Jones Indices LLC. Data as of June 30, 2026. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Chart is provided for illustrative purposes.

Despite greater scope to add value, results in the SPIVA Europe Mid-Year 2026 Scorecard varied widely across categories, as Exhibit 2 shows. While 90% of U.K. Large-/Mid-Cap Equity funds and 86% of U.K. Equity funds underperformed YTD, the rates were 47% for small-cap funds, 42% for GBP corporate bond funds and 18% for GBP government bond funds.

Unequal Opportunities: SPIVA Europe U.K. Active Fund Performance in H1 2026: Exhibit 2

Source: S&P Dow Jones Indices LLC, Morningstar. Data as of June 30, 2026. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Chart is provided for illustrative purposes.

Rather than revisit the familiar challenges facing active funds, the focus turns to categories where most managers outperformed, starting with small-cap equities. Perhaps the most obvious explanation for their success is a systematic size bias. The S&P United Kingdom LargeMidCap gained 9% in H1 2026, compared with 3% for the S&P United Kingdom SmallCap. A bias to larger companies could therefore have helped performance. However, Exhibit 3 groups U.K. Small-Cap Equity funds by average portfolio market capitalization decile and shows no clear relationship between size and performance.

Unequal Opportunities: SPIVA Europe U.K. Active Fund Performance in H1 2026: Exhibit 3

Source: S&P Dow Jones Indices LLC, FactSet. Data as of June 30, 2026. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Chart is provided for illustrative purposes.

With size bias unlikely to explain small-cap managers’ success, dispersion offers another possible explanation. U.K. small-cap dispersion exceeded large- and mid-cap dispersion in H1 2026. However, this has been true for the past decade, while manager outperformance has been inconsistent.2

The difference may therefore lie not in the level of dispersion, but in its source. Exhibit 4 shows that sector contributions to small-cap dispersion rose sharply to their highest level since the series began in December 2006. This may have created greater opportunities for funds positioned in the right sectors than in recent years.

Unequal Opportunities: SPIVA Europe U.K. Active Fund Performance in H1 2026: Exhibit 4

Source: S&P Dow Jones Indices LLC. Data as of June 30, 2026. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Chart is provided for illustrative purposes.

Beyond equities, fixed income was also fertile ground for active managers, with return skewness a possible factor. In equities, a small number of stocks can account for an outsized portion of index performance.3 Fixed income often shows the opposite pattern, with a few poor performers dragging down the index while the median constituent outperforms.

This was evident across GBP fixed income in H1 2026. Exhibit 5 shows that over 50% of constituents in both corporate and government bond indices outperformed their respective indices. Avoiding the largest detractors therefore may have offered active funds a route to outperformance.

Unequal Opportunities: SPIVA Europe U.K. Active Fund Performance in H1 2026: Exhibit 5

Source: S&P Dow Jones Indices LLC. Data as of June 30, 2026. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Chart is provided for illustrative purposes.

In the first half of 2026, U.K. markets illustrated that opportunity does not guarantee active fund outperformance. Success also depends on the form that opportunity takes and funds’ ability to take advantage of it, highlighting the value of looking beyond headline performance numbers.

1 Edwards, Tim, and Craig J. Lazzara. “Dispersion: Measuring Market Opportunity” S&P Dow Jones Indices. December 2013.

2 Smith, Euan. “One to Forget: SPIVA Europe U.K. Equity Active Fund Performance in 2025” S&P Dow Jones Indices. April 7, 2026.

3 Ganti, Anu. “Skewing Success” S&P Dow Jones Indices. Sept. 30, 2025.

This content may be AI-assisted and is composed, reviewed, edited, and approved by S&P Global.

The posts on this blog are opinions, not advice. Please read our Disclaimers.


Up, but Not Across

Contributor Image
Sara Pineros

Quantitative Analyst, Index Investment Strategy

S&P Dow Jones Indices

Among many rising European equity markets, Spain had one of the stronger starts to the year, surpassing countries such as France (up 4%), the U.K. (up 9%) and Ireland (up 11%) in the first half of 2026. The S&P Spain BMI gained 14% YTD through June 30, 2026, outperforming the S&P Europe 350® (up 11%) and the S&P Eurozone BMI (up 12%) (see Exhibit 1).1

Spain Outpaced European Benchmarks in H1 2026: Exhibit 1

Yet strong index gains do not, in themselves, make life easier for active managers. In the SPIVA® Europe Mid-Year 2026 Scorecard, 98% of the 50 Spain Equity funds underperformed the S&P Spain BMI, a higher share than in other major European markets, including Germany (48%), France (61%) and Italy (81%). Underperformance was similarly high across the 1-, 3-, 5- and 10-year periods.

The striking feature is not simply that underperformance was widespread, but that it was high relative to history (see Exhibit 2). Over the past decade, the average annual underperformance rate was 64%, while in years such as 2015 and 2024 it fell as low as 24%. Why, then, was it so difficult for Spanish fund managers to keep pace with the benchmark in the first half of 2026?

Share of Spain Equity Funds Underperforming the Benchmark (2015-H1 2026): Exhibit 2

One thing that did change in H1 2026 was the spread of stock-level performance. Average dispersion across S&P Spain BMI constituents, measured on a trailing six-month basis, rose from 19% at the end of December 2025 to 22% by June 2026. A wider gap between the best and worst performers generally give stock pickers more to work with, but only if they own the right stocks.

But rising dispersion did not mean broad leadership. In Spain, leadership was concentrated, with most of the index’s performance driven by three sectors: Industrials, Utilities and Financials, which together accounted for roughly three-quarters of the index's weight (see Exhibit 3). In a market with narrow leadership, funds with less exposure to a sufficient number of high-performing stocks from those sectors relative to the benchmark could have faced a headwind.

Most Outperforming Stocks Were in the Largest Sectors: Exhibit 3

Performance also diverged by size. In H1 2026, the S&P Spain MidCap gained 22%, compared with 14% for the S&P Spain LargeCap and 9% for the S&P Spain SmallCap. This reversed the pattern seen in 2025, when large caps led by a wide margin (see Exhibit 4). The strength of mid-cap stocks in the first half of 2026 may have been missed by some managers who were more focused on the larger constituents in the benchmark.

Spanish Equities – Index Performance by Market-Cap Segment (2025 Versus H1 2026): Exhibit 4

So, what did the first half of 2026 teach us about Spain? Outperformance proved hard to come by; even with growing dispersion across S&P Spain BMI constituents and a clear lead for mid caps, gains were concentrated in a handful of sectors and 98% of funds still trailed the benchmark. Predicting where active managers go from here is likely to be just as difficult as predicting where the market goes next. Will the pattern hold or reverse by year-end? Only time will tell, so stay tuned for our SPIVA Europe Year-End 2026 Scorecard to see how the year unfolded in Spain and across broader Europe.

 

1 Index performance based on total return in EUR.

The posts on this blog are opinions, not advice. Please read our Disclaimers.


One Toolkit, Many Markets: The Global Evolution of Options-Based ETFs

Contributor Image
Tim Edwards, Ph.D.

Managing Director and Global Head of Index Investment Strategy

S&P Dow Jones Indices

The Trackinsight Global ETF Survey 2026 depicts an ETF industry moving from access to selection. As the product shelf expands, investors increasingly need to understand not simply what exposure an ETF provides, but what role it performs and which trade-offs it introduces. Options-based ETFs provide a clear example of that shift and are examined in particular detail by the survey.

Options-based ETFs have reached meaningful scale. By Trackinsight’s classifications, the category reached USD 384.3 billion across 1,459 products by July 2026. It took in USD 105.3 billion in 2025 and another USD 77.4 billion in the first seven months of 2026. Scale has been accompanied by a broader portfolio role, spanning income, growth, volatility reduction, downside protection and diversification.

Demand Is Taking Different Forms

Among the professional respondents included in the regional analysis, 69% of the North American group planned to invest in income-generating options-based ETFs over the next 12 months. The equivalent figure in Europe was 22%. The reasons for that demand also differed. In Europe, volatility reduction led at 48%, compared with 25% in North America. Greater downside protection also ranked highly among the factors for European investors. The regional samples were small, so the numbers should be treated as indicative. They nevertheless raise useful questions about how the options toolkit will be deployed within the industry.

One Toolkit, Many Markets: The Global Evolution of Options-Based ETFs: Exhibit 1

The U.S. remained the largest market, but adoption is spreading internationally. By March 2026, options-based ETF assets had reached about USD 30 billion in Canada, USD 8.6 billion in South Korea, USD 8.0 billion in Europe and USD 4.1 billion in Hong Kong.

The product mix varied as well. Covered calls prevailed outside the U.S., but markets differed in their use of active management, index tracking and option underlyings. Canada made extensive use of single-stock options. U.S. indices were more prominent in Europe and Japan, while local indices prevailed in Hong Kong. These markets show how product design is adapting to local demand, regulation, distribution and market structure.

One Toolkit, Many Markets: The Global Evolution of Options-Based ETFs: Exhibit 2

A Global Ecosystem Supports Differentiated Products

Regional objectives and product structures may differ, but many strategies draw on common underlying options markets. The S&P 500® is a leading example. Its options ecosystem spans strikes, maturities and trading hours, including index options, options on futures, options on ETFs and an active over-the-counter structured market. This breadth supports daily, monthly, quarterly and annual covered call, buffered, and other strategy designs, with a broad range of market participants contributing to trading and pricing.

Liquidity outside U.S. trading hours has also increased. Average daily traded notional in listed S&P 500 options during non-U.S. hours reached about USD 132 billion in 2025, compared with USD 5 billion in 2014.1 That liquidity can support products designed for different markets, wrappers and reset schedules.

One Toolkit, Many Markets: The Global Evolution of Options-Based ETFs: Exhibit 3

Design choices remain consequential. Strike, maturity, reset frequency and entry point can materially change the balance between income, protection and upside participation. Those choices depend on access to liquid instruments and effective implementation. Trading ecosystems around established benchmarks have therefore supported the development of these exposures in ETFs.

Understanding Remains a Constraint; Indices Can Bring Clarity

Trackinsight respondents cited complexity and unfamiliarity more often than cost or compliance as barriers to greater use of options-based ETFs. The result is understandable. A covered call, a buffer and a tail-risk strategy may all use options, but their expected behavior is quite different. “Options-based” does not indicate which role a product might play in a portfolio.

Investors therefore need to understand the outcome being sought and how the strategy is intended to pursue it. What income or protection is being targeted? Is upside participation reduced or enhanced, and over what period? When does the strategy reset? How might it behave in a strong rise or a sharp fall in the market? Larger investors may also need to consider derivatives liquidity, capacity, collateral, valuation and trading costs.

This is where indices have a distinct role. Established benchmarks can support the underlying derivatives ecosystem. Strategy indices can encode choices about strikes, maturities, resets and protection in transparent rules. Relevant benchmarks can then provide a basis for comparing both index-tracking and actively managed implementations, and for assessing whether a strategy delivered the outcome it was designed to provide.

The ETF wrapper can make an options strategy easier to access. The broad range of indices offered by S&P Dow Jones Indices, both as underlying benchmarks and as transparent representations of options-based strategies, can make a strategy’s purpose and trade-offs easier to understand. As the market continues to innovate, the products most likely to earn a lasting portfolio role will be those whose intended outcomes can be clearly explained, consistently measured and appropriately compared.

Read the Trackinsight Global ETF Survey 2026 for the full findings on how professional investors, including allocators, fund selectors, wealth managers and other institutional investors, are selecting and using ETFs. For a closer examination of options-based strategy design and benchmarking, explore Defining Paths with Options-Based Index Strategies. The Trackinsight Global ETF Survey 2026 was sponsored by S&P Dow Jones Indices.

1 Lee, Sue, “Beyond Borders: The Significance of the S&P 500 in Options-Based Strategies,” S&P Dow Jones Indices, May 4, 2026.

2 Lee, Sue, “Defining Paths with Options-Based Index Strategies,” S&P Dow Jones Indices, Feb. 24, 2026.

This content may be AI-assisted and is composed, reviewed, edited, and approved by S&P Global.

The posts on this blog are opinions, not advice. Please read our Disclaimers.


The Changing Calculus of Diversification

Contributor Image
Agatha Malinowski

Quantitative Associate, Index Investment Strategy

S&P Dow Jones Indices

During tumultuous equity market environments like the present, characterized by heightened AI-related anxiety, asset owners have often turned to fixed income in search of protection. This year, however, bonds have offered little refuge. Treasury yields have risen and continue to fluctuate as markets reassess inflation and the path of Fed policy. Most recently, a hotter-than-expected October CPI print pushed yields across the curve back toward or above 5%, while a roughly in-line PPI reading later in the week put further pressure on the long end. Together, these shifts have created a challenging backdrop for both stocks and bonds.

The traditional 60/40 portfolio,1 which allocates 60% to equities and 40% to fixed income, has long relied on bonds2 to help offset equity market losses. More recently, persistent inflation, fiscal deficit concerns and the reliance of mega-cap hyperscalers on the debt markets for financing may have contributed to stocks and bonds becoming increasingly sensitive to similar risks. The diversification benefits that supported the 60/40 framework for decades have appeared to weaken, with six-month rolling stock-bond correlations remaining positive for much of 2026, as shown in Exhibit 1. More recently, however, that relationship may have begun to shift, with the S&P 500® falling 1% in October while the iBoxx USD Treasuries gained more than 2%.

The Changing Calculus of Diversification: Exhibit 1

Given these headwinds, asset owners have historically looked beyond stocks and bonds for additional sources of diversification. For perspective, we can compare a traditional 60/40 stock-bond blend with a theoretical multi-asset blend. The multi-asset blend retained a 60% weight to equities and spread the remaining 40% among Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (TIPS), gold, U.S. dollar futures and Treasury bills, asset classes influenced by different inflation, interest rate and liquidity dynamics.

Exhibit 2 compares the historical performance of the multi-asset blend with the S&P 500 and a traditional 60/40 stock-bond blend over the past 10 years. While the S&P 500 posted the highest absolute performance, the multi-asset blend outperformed the traditional 60/40 blend.

The Changing Calculus of Diversification: Exhibit 2

Performance, however, tells only part of the story. Asset classes like equities have historically coincided with greater volatility. Over the same period, annualized volatility was 18% for the S&P 500 and 11% for both the traditional 60/40 blend and the multi-asset blend. Exhibit 3 shows that the multi-asset blend had the highest risk-adjusted performance among the three approaches.

The Changing Calculus of Diversification: Exhibit 3

Fluctuations in Treasury yields and an evolving macro landscape have challenged traditional approaches to diversification. While the recent decline in stock-bond correlations may offer some relief, its durability remains uncertain. Indices could help identify and measure evolving sources of diversification across asset classes. As market regimes change, so may the assets that help manage risk.

1    Hakyung K. “Chart of the Week: Is the 60-40 portfolio dead?” Financial Times, Aug. 29, 2026.

2    Pham, Nga, Bei Cui and Ummul Ruthbah. “The Performance of the 60/40 Portfolio: A Historical Perspective.” CFA Institute, Research and Policy Center, Feb. 18, 2025.

The posts on this blog are opinions, not advice. Please read our Disclaimers.


Droning On About Defense: A Reimagined Vision for Europe

Contributor Image
Vidushan Ragukaran

Director, Global Equities & Thematic Indices

S&P Dow Jones Indices

Defense has had more than just its 15 minutes this year.

On the football pitch, Spain demonstrated the value of a formidable defense, conceding just once en route to winning the 2026 World Cup.1 Yet the rhetoric surrounding England’s exit fixated on almost the opposite claim: too much defense can cost you.

Building From the Back

In Europe’s rather more consequential defense debate, one common refrain has been that more spending is a must. Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, conflict in the Middle East and a changing geopolitical order have sharpened the focus on military preparedness.

EU member states spent EUR 418 billion on defense in 2025, equivalent to 2.2% of GDP, with expenditure estimated to reach EUR 454 billion, or 2.4%, in 2026.2 At the 2025 NATO Summit, Allies committed to spending 5% of GDP annually on defense and security-related requirements by 2035, including at least 3.5% on core defense.3 Europe is also turning commitments into procurement through instruments including the EU’s EUR 150 billion SAFE facility.4

Against this backdrop, Exhibit 1 charts the historical performance of the S&P Europe Defense Vision Index alongside rising European defense expenditure. Geopolitical events have punctuated performance, but the spending trajectory points to a potentially more structural shift underpinning Europe’s defense story.

Droning On About Defense: A Reimagined Vision for Europe: Exhibit 1

Rethinking the Arsenal

What Europe spends that money on matters too.

A modern military still requires missiles, ships and armored vehicles. But increasingly, it also relies on drones and autonomous systems, radar and guidance systems, battlefield communications, satellites, cyber capabilities and software. NATO Allies have committed more than USD 40 billion to counter-drone capabilities over five years, while the U.K. has allocated more than GBP 5 billion to drones and autonomous-system transformation.5, 6

Private capital is moving in the same direction. European defense start-ups had raised USD 7.4 billion by Sept. 20, 2026, versus USD 2.6 billion in all of 2025, with drones and autonomous systems accounting for 74% of EU defense-tech funding.7 German-based Helsing alone raised USD 1.8 billion at a USD 18 billion valuation.8

This is where S&P Global Business Involvement Screens data adds an important dimension. Military Contracting revenue exposure spans Integral Military Weapons, Weapon-Related Products and Non-Weapon-Related Products. As Exhibit 2 illustrates, this reflects not just weapons, but the technologies, components and services underpinning modern military capabilities.

Droning On About Defense: A Reimagined Vision for Europe: Exhibit 2

Making the Cut

That broader interpretation is reflected in the index. At the October 2026 rebalance, Military Contracting involvement represented 70.2% of the S&P Europe Defense Vision Index on a constituent-weighted basis, while Weapons exposure stood at just 10.9%. Defense Technology & Products accounted for 28.1%, alongside activity in other areas including cybersecurity.

Exhibit 3 puts these characteristics into context. Relative to both the April 2026 rebalance composition and a more traditional GICS® industry approach, the October rebalance emphasizes military contracting and defense technology more heavily, with less exposure to aerospace. The increase in Military Contracting involvement, a sign of greater thematic purity, also reflects a growing pool of eligible, pureplay European defense companies. Although not explicitly targeted, greater European revenue exposure also aligns with the push for regional defense autonomy.

Droning On About Defense: A Reimagined Vision for Europe: Exhibit 3

Europe’s defense landscape is no longer confined to conventional aerospace and defense. Weapons and combat platforms remain critical, but drones and autonomy, cyber, communications, space and software increasingly form part of the wider ecosystem.

And Europe’s defense plans extend well beyond a halftime team talk. As Europe commits more resources to defense, the threats it faces and capabilities required to address them will continue to evolve. Keeping pace with that evolution will likely require not only greater spending, but a longer-term vision of what defense may become.

By looking beyond traditional sector boundaries while retaining a direct link to military business involvement, the S&P Europe Defense Vision Index offers a distinct lens for tracking Europe’s evolving defense era.

 

References:

1 FIFA. “Spain Complete Unprecedented Global Double as New Milestones on the Pitch Define Historic FIFA World Cup 2026 Finale.” July 20, 2026.

2 European Defence Agency. “EU Defence Spending: €418 Billion in 2025, Projected to €454 Billion in 2026.” July 16, 2026.

3 NATO. “The Hague Summit Declaration.” June 25, 2025.

4 European Commission. “SAFE”.

5 NATO. “NATO Allies Invest 40 Billion Dollars in Counter-Drone Capabilities and Drone Training.” July 7, 2026.

6 UK Ministry of Defence. “UK Drone Transformation to Strengthen Armed Forces Backed by More Than £5 Billion.” June 29, 2026.

7 Dealroom.co and Resilience Media. “State of Defence Tech 2026.” October 2026.

8 Defense News. “Helsing Raises $1.8 Billion in Europe’s Biggest Defense-Startup Round.” July 13, 2026.

The posts on this blog are opinions, not advice. Please read our Disclaimers.