Register with us today

and in less than 60 seconds continue your access to:Latest news headlinesAnalytical topics and featuresCommodities videos, podcast & blogsSample market prices & dataSpecial reportsSubscriber notes & daily commodity email alerts

Already have an account?

Log in to register

Forgot Password

Please Note: Platts Market Center subscribers can only reset passwords via the Platts Market Center

Enter your Email ID below and we will send you an email with your password.

  • Email Address* Please enter email address.

If you are a premium subscriber, we are unable to send you your password for security reasons. Please contact the Client Services team.

If you are a Platts Market Center subscriber, to reset your password go to the Platts Market Center to reset your password.

In this list
Natural Gas

Maine natural gas pipeline proposals don't offer enough benefits: report

LNG | Natural Gas | Natural Gas (North American) | Oil | Crude Oil

Has the oil market found balance?

LNG | Natural Gas | NGL

Platts LNG Alert

Capital Markets | Commodities | Electricity | Energy | LNG | Natural Gas | Shipping | Leveraged Finance & High Yield | Materials | Building & Construction | Financial Services | Banking | Infrastructure | Structured Finance

Infrastructure Summit

Natural Gas

National Grid to use trucked LNG, CNG in peak US Northeast winter gas demand periods

Maine natural gas pipeline proposals don't offer enough benefits: report


The cost of proposals to expand natural gas pipeline capacity to Maine outweigh the benefits, according to a report drafted by a consulting firm hired by the Maine Public Utilities Commission.

Not registered?

Receive daily email alerts, subscriber notes & personalize your experience.

Register Now

The findings come as New England governors are working to increase gas pipeline capacity to help lower electricity prices, especially in the winter when gas use soars to fuel power plants and heating systems.

In an effort to lower power prices, the Maine Legislature in 2013 authorized the PUC to spend up to $75 million a year to buy up to 200 MMcf/day of gas through an "energy cost reduction contract" (ECRC) that would be paid for by electric ratepayers if it was cost effective.

Through a solicitation process, the PUC received project offers from Spectra Energy, Tennessee Gas Pipeline and Portland Natural Gas Transmission System.

In a redacted report released late last week, Boston-based London Economics International found that the offers do not provide enough cost savings to Maine consumers to make them worthwhile.

"The results of LEI's analysis -- that the benefits the ECRCs [bring] to Maine consumers are too small to exceed costs to Maine -- are driven by the relatively low level of gas and power consumed in Maine as compared to the New England region," the report said.

New England uses about 2,400 MMBtu/day on average, while Maine uses only about 160 MMBtu/d, or about 7% of the region's total, according to the report. Massachusetts uses about half of New England's gas, followed by Connecticut at about 25%.

Similarly, Maine accounted for about 9% of New England's electric use in 2014.

Reflecting the usage rates, if gas prices fell by 25 cents/MMBtu, Maine would see $14.6 million in savings while Massachusetts' costs would fall by $106.7 million, the report said.

Each of the pipeline proposals has "a noticeable but not game-changing effect" on Algonquin city-gate gas prices and the difference in pricing effects between the projects was small, the report said.


In its analysis, LEI assumed that Maine's average wholesale prices would fall from about $43/MWh this year to about $36/MWh in 2018, partly because of current projects to expand import pipeline capacity in New England.

After that, prices rise gradually to about $52/MWh in 2029, according to LEI's forecast.

The consulting firm assumed the gas would cost $5.85/MMBtu in 2028. Of the proposals, Spectra Energy's Atlantic Bridge project would have the biggest effect on Algonquin city-gate gas prices by lowering them to $5.54/MMBtu in 2028, which would have the effect of lowering power prices in Maine by $2.44/MWh, it said.

Atlantic Bridge would lower total electric wholesale costs by $86.5 million through 2028, while the other proposals would provide less savings, according to the report. Total savings for electric and gas customers would range from $80 million to $135 million through 2028, it added.

The Conservation Law Foundation said Friday that the report supports the environmental group's opposition to the plan to expand pipeline capacity for Maine via an ECRC contract. "The conclusions drawn by the PUC's expert consultant in their report should prevent Maine from entering into such a contract any time soon," the group said.

In May, Central Maine Power, Maine's largest utility said it planned to participate in one of the proposed projects, known as Access Northeast. The $3 billion Spectra Energy project would expand the Algonquin and Maritimes & Northeast pipeline systems to deliver an additional 1 Bcf/d to New England by November 2018. The project could serve power plants totaling at least 5,000 MW, according to Spectra.

--Ethan Howland,
--Edited by Keiron Greenhalgh,