trending Market Intelligence /marketintelligence/en/news-insights/trending/o2XbCE50aKvRwF0VJCtCQw2 content
Log in to other products

Login to Market Intelligence Platform


Looking for more?

Contact Us
In This List

Commodity ETFs command mixed investor confidence, drab returns in 2018

Greenhouse gas and gold mines Nearly 1 ton of CO2 emitted per ounce of gold produced in 2019

Essential Metals & Mining Insights - September 2020

Essential Metals & Mining Insights - August 2020

State of the Market: Mining Q2-2020

Commodity ETFs command mixed investor confidence, drab returns in 2018

Investor confidence in commodity-focused exchange-traded funds varied in 2018 even as overall performance was lackluster.

Gold equity ETFs, which invest directly in mining stocks, reversed a median net inflow of US$8.1 million in 2017 to an outflow of US$5.1 million in 2018. The eight ETFs included in the analysis saw mixed client flows but unanimous negative total returns in 2018, resulting in a median negative total return of 12.2% for the year, from a positive 9.8% yield in 2017.

Four gold equity ETFs saw net inflows in 2018, led by VanEck Vectors Gold Miners ETF that saw the largest net inflow for the year of US$3.62 billion and the largest AUM by year-end at US$10.39 billion. VanEck's smaller Junior Gold Miners ETF followed, albeit distantly, with a US$284.4 million net inflow for the year that took year-end AUM to US$4.21 billion.

Of the gold-equity ETFs that had outflows, iShares MSCI Global Gold Miners ETF took the lead after ceding US$126.7 million for the year to ultimately end the year with AUM at US$172.3 million. Sprott Junior Gold Miners ETF had the second-largest net outflow of US$75.0 million for the year that left AUM at US$41.3 million.

Negative one-year total returns were observed across the board, equivalent to 10.7% for VanEck Vectors Gold Miners, 10.2% for VanEck Junior Gold Miners and 14.8% for iShares MSCI Global Gold Miners. Sprott Junior Gold Miners had the largest negative total return for the year among all gold equity ETFs at 24.0%.

SNL Image

Precious metals-focused ETFs saw a slowdown in net inflows year over year in 2018, with median net inflows at US$5.2 million, versus US$10.2 million in 2017. Net inflows and negative one-year total returns dominated for the year in review.

Despite bucking the bias for inflows with a net outflow of US$1.80 billion in 2018, SPDR Gold Trust, which follows the gold spot price and invests in physical gold, still managed to end the year with the largest AUM at US$32.38 billion. Its one-year total return was negative 2.8%, at par with the median for all commodity ETFs.

SPDR Gold Trust competitor iShares Gold Trust had the largest net inflow of US$1.60 billion in 2018, helping the ETF end the year with the second-largest AUM at US$11.52 billion.

Aberdeen Standard Physical Platinum Shares ETF, which ended the year with US$492.7 million in AUM, had the largest negative one-year total return of 15.7%. An exception to negative returns, ETFS Physical Palladium Shares yielded 21.4% in positive one-year total returns, despite logging an annual outflow of US$72.9 million for the year that left year-end AUM at US$186.5 million.