Plug-in hybrid cars with electric and gasoline motors under one hood are an important part of the evolution toward fully electric cars as batteries steadily improve, but their green credentials are running up against an unforeseen problem — a lack of "sincerity."
Subsidies and tax breaks for cars that offer unlimited range plus zero-emissions capability in urban environments have attracted droves of fleet buyers, but research by U.K.-based fleet fuel management company TMC in November 2018
"If you want to have [PHEV] mobility that gives you range on weekends and zero-emissions capability on weekdays, then you need to demonstrate your sincerity," Peugeot SA CEO Carlos Tavares told reporters at the Geneva Motor Show on March 5.
Tavares insisted — against colleagues' wishes — that Peugeot PHEVs feature a tell-tale blue light visible from outside signaling that the car is in zero-emissions mode, a feature he hopes will prompt drivers to charge up and run on batteries more often, especially in built-up areas.
"They didn't like the idea so I had to force them to do it," Tavares said.
As PHEVs are designed to be charged at home, in some cases the problem could be one of laziness. But it may just as often be down to the difficulty of accessing sockets or the lack of alternative charging points.
Although early skepticism of battery-electric cars has subsided as renewables gradually decarbonize the power grid, plug-in hybrid technology is dividing opinion, in no small part due to its reliance on good faith.
Mitsubishi Motors Corp. has had major sales success with its plug-in hybrid Outlander SUV, which achieves unprecedented fuel economy for a car of its size. However, Toyota Motor Corp., which in 1997 brought the world the first commercially available hybrid car, the Prius, has since expanded the gasoline-electric powertrain to almost all of its range but has restricted a plug-in option to the Prius only. Recent marketing has focused on the self-charging variant without the plug.
It is "arguably the best of both worlds but also arguably the worst of both worlds," said Al Bedwell, a global powertrain analyst at U.K.-based consultancy LMC Automotive, in an interview.
That is truer than ever in the U.K. market since rule changes in October 2018 stipulating that plug-in hybrid cars must be capable of at least 70 miles of zero-emissions driving to qualify for a £3,500 grant toward the cost of the car.
Only vehicles with larger, heavier batteries that are capable of this range now qualify. These cars should help cut air pollution with diminished needs for engine power but could potentially worsen it if driven with flat batteries.
"You get these distortions of the market by policies which weren't very well thought through. Often, the people setting these tax breaks don't necessarily understand or haven't thought that deeply about the implications," Bedwell said.
"We are not saying that the PHEV sector with the big battery and the big range is going to die overnight, but we don't see it as a long-term winner. It's not going to give the benefit unless you actually plug it in, which you don't have to do. You'd be surprised how many people don't," Bedwell said.
Peugeot's Tavares described plug-in hybrids as "expensive" because of their dual powertrains, but as major European cities clamp down on emissions, in places banning diesel cars sometimes less than five years old, he said there is no equivalent for drivers who cover long distances but also need to navigate the urban jungle unhindered by tightening regulations.
Bayerische Motoren Werke AG CEO Harald Krüger went further. He said plug-in hybrid cars are here to stay since it may never prove feasible to provide sufficient charging points to turn battery-electric cars into a universal solution. That is particularly true in some developing countries where both road and electricity grid infrastructure are poorly developed.
"It's not a transitional technology. It will be a full end technology because the infrastructure will not be everywhere so that you can charge cars everywhere in every location," Krüger told S&P Global Market Intelligence at the Geneva Motor Show.
But where power is plentiful, Krüger said evidence has shown average drivers of longer-range PHEVs may rarely need the combustion engine at all.
"We have research that says if you cover a [daily] distance of about 60 to 70 kilometers, you are driving as much on electric as you typically drive in a pure electric car."