In this list
Natural Gas

Russia's Nord Stream 2 loses court case against new EU gas rules

Commodities | Energy | Electric Power | Nuclear | Energy Transition | Emissions | Carbon | Renewables | LNG | Natural Gas | Natural Gas (European) | Oil | Crude Oil | Refined Products | Metals | Non-Ferrous | Steel | Steel Raw Materials

Market Movers Europe, Nov. 28-Dec. 2: Oil market eyes G7 oil price cap and EU ban, as OPEC+ congregates in Vienna

Energy | LNG | Natural Gas | NGL

Platts LP Gaswire

Oil | Natural Gas | LNG | Carbon | Emissions | Energy Transition | Electric Power | Coal | Energy | Electricity | Biofuels | Commodities

COP27

Energy | Natural Gas

Germany's Uniper initiates arbitration proceedings against Gazprom Export

Commodities | Agriculture | Grains | Energy | LNG | Natural Gas | Natural Gas (European) | Oil | Crude Oil | Shipping | Dry Freight

Commodity Tracker: 4 charts to watch this week

For full access to real-time updates, breaking news, analysis, pricing and data visualization subscribe today.

Subscribe Now

Russia's Nord Stream 2 loses court case against new EU gas rules

Highlights

Court finds no grounds for direct challenge at EU level

Further blow after German regulator rejected waiver

NS2 facing EU tariff, access rules for German section

  • Author
  • Siobhan Hall
  • Editor
  • Derek Sands
  • Commodity
  • Natural Gas

Brussels — Russia's Nord Stream 2 gas link developer has lost its court case against changes that apply EU gas market rules to the EU section of offshore links with non-EU countries.

Not registered?

Receive daily email alerts, subscriber notes & personalize your experience.

Register Now

The EU General Court dismissed the complaint on Wednesday, saying that Nord Stream 2 was not directly concerned by the changes to the EU's gas directive as the rules were transposed and applied with some discretion by national governments, and therefore any complaint should be directed at the national level.

Nord Stream 2 had argued that complying with the new obligations would force it to sell the whole 55 Bcm/year pipeline from Russia to Germany to meet unbundling requirements, or "entirely alter its organizational and business structure," fundamentally weakening its investment case.

The ruling comes just days after German energy regulator Bundesnetzagentur rejected Nord Stream 2's formal request in January for a waiver from the changes, which have applied since May 2019.

Without the waiver, the Gazprom-owned project faces having to comply with EU third-party access, unbundling and tariff transparency rules for the section in German waters, once it becomes operational.

BNetzA said such waivers can only be granted to pipelines completed before May 23, 2019.

Russian President Vladimir Putin said earlier this year he expected Nord Stream 2 to come online by the first quarter of 2021 at the latest.

There are just 160 km (99 miles) of pipe left to lay in Danish waters.

Appeal options

The EU General Court's ruling can be appealed on points of law only within two months and 10 days.

Nord Stream 2 also has the right to challenge any exemption decision by BNetzA before a German court by claiming the gas directives changes were "invalid," the EU court said.

It would then be up to the German court to ask the EU Court of Justice, the EU's highest court, for a reference ruling on whether the changes are valid.

Nord Stream 2 has until June 14 to appeal the BNetzA decision.